| Carnell Tate | DeVonta Smith | |
|---|---|---|
| Team | TEN | PHI |
| Age | 21 | 27 |
| WR rank by value | WR18 | WR19 |
| 1QB value | 4,197 | 4,113 |
| Superflex value | 3,180 | 3,214 |
| Overall rank (1QB / SF) | #36 / #53 | #37 / #51 |
| PPR PPG (2026) | 9.7 | 16.2 |
| Injury status | Active | Active |
| Source agreement | Some disagreement (spread 48%) | Some disagreement (spread 54%) |
| DynastyProcess value | 5,188 | 5,092 |
| Sleeper value | 3,630 | 2,317 |
| nflverse value | 2,687 | 5,092 |
Fair-trade verdict
| Format | Carnell Tate | DeVonta Smith | Gap | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1QB | 4,197 | 4,113 | 2.0% | Fair trade |
| Superflex | 3,180 | 3,214 | 1.1% | Fair trade |
Same rule as the trade calculator: gap = (larger − smaller) ÷ larger; within 5% is fair. Favors means the side receiving that player gets the better value.
Buy/sell flags
- DeVonta Smith: possible buy (market below experts)
Carnell Tate is 6 years younger (21 vs 27). DeVonta Smith is scoring more in 2026: 16.2 vs 9.7 PPR points per game.
Frequently asked questions
Who is worth more in dynasty, Carnell Tate or DeVonta Smith?
Carnell Tate is valued higher in 1QB leagues, by 84 points (4,197 vs 4,113) as of October 18, 2026. In superflex it is 3,180 vs 3,214.
Is Carnell Tate for DeVonta Smith a fair dynasty trade?
In 1QB leagues, a straight swap is a fair trade (the gap is 2.0%, within the 5% fair range). In superflex it is a fair trade (the gap is 1.1%, within the 5% fair range).
Who is younger, Carnell Tate or DeVonta Smith, and who scores more?
Carnell Tate is 6 years younger (21 vs 27). DeVonta Smith is scoring more in 2026: 16.2 vs 9.7 PPR points per game.
More
- Carnell Tate dynasty value
- DeVonta Smith dynasty value
- Dynasty WR rankings
- All dynasty player comparisons
- Should I start Carnell Tate this week?
- Should I start DeVonta Smith this week?
Open Carnell Tate vs DeVonta Smith in the trade calculator
Composite values from DynastyProcess (40%), Sleeper (30%), nflverse (15%) (weights re-normalised over the sources available today); expert values from DynastyProcess open data (GPL-3.0); nflverse data CC BY 4.0, changed by us into per-game production ranks. Projections: Sleeper public API. Updated October 18, 2026. How the composite works. Values are a starting point, not a guarantee.